Image Database Export Citations


Communal Governance and Private Ownership of Water Rights

Show full item record

Type: Conference Paper
Author: Smith, Steven
Conference: In Defense of the Commons: Challenges, Innovation and Action, the Seventeenth Biennial Conference of the International Association for the Study of the Commons
Location: Lima, Peru
Conf. Date: July 1-5
Date: 2019
URI: https://hdl.handle.net/10535/10661
Sector: Water Resource & Irrigation
Region: North America
Subject(s): irrigation
Abstract: "The prior appropriation doctrine adopted by all 17 Western US States, in which water users are provided absolute, private rights to water allocated in order of first diversion, has been lauded for its incentive structure for initial development but critiqued for subsequent inequalities in water use. By contrast, Hispanic settlers of the region adopted proportional water rights. I compare the performance of proportional water rights to the more prevalent private rights (prior appropriation) using theory and empirical evidence. I test the theoretical predictions using a natural experiment where acequias (Hispanic-rooted irrigation ditches) developed in Territorial New Mexico are later divided by the formation of Colorado, exogenously forcing that subset to be subject to the priority system while those in New Mexico continue to practice proportional division today. With 1930 irrigation organization data, I first test the implications on infrastructure investment, finding that indeed more investment has been made in Colorado and increases in seniority of rights. Then, using annual satellite imagery from 1984-2011, I compare performance under various stream flow conditions, finding that the marginal product of water is generally larger under the proportional system. Finally, using survey data from 2013 I explore how governance form and concerns of these Hispanic organizations have distinctly evolved given the presence of, or lack thereof, the prior appropriation doctrine."

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
9F2.pdf 1.762Mb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following document type(s)

Show full item record