Image Database Export Citations


Expert and Generalist Local Knowledge about Land-cover Change on South Africas Wild Coast: Can Local Ecological Knowledge Add Value to Science?

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.author Chalmers, Nigel en_US
dc.contributor.author Fabricius, Christo en_US
dc.date.accessioned 2009-07-31T14:57:05Z
dc.date.available 2009-07-31T14:57:05Z
dc.date.issued 2007 en_US
dc.date.submitted 2009-02-10 en_US
dc.date.submitted 2009-02-10 en_US
dc.identifier.uri https://hdl.handle.net/10535/3090
dc.description.abstract "Local ecological knowledge (LEK) can shed light on ecosystem change, especially in under-researched areas such as South Africas Wild Coast. However, for ecosystem planning purposes, it is necessary to assess the accuracy and validity of LEK, and determine where such knowledge is situated in a community, and how evenly it is spread. Furthermore, it is relevant to ask: does LEK add value to science, and how do science and local knowledge complement one another? We assessed change in woodland and forest cover in the Nqabara Administrative Area on South Africas Wild Coast between 1974 and 2001. The inhabitants of Nqabara are traditional Xhosa-speaking people who are highly dependent on natural resources for their livelihoods. More recently, however, infrastructural development has influenced traditional lifestyles at Nqabara, although poverty remains high and formal education levels low. We assessed LEK about changes in woodland and forest cover over the past 30 years by interviewing 11 local experts, who were recognized as such by the Nqabara community, and 40 senior members of randomly selected households in each village. We also analyzed land-cover change, using orthorectified aerial photos taken in 1974 and 2001. Forest and woodland cover had increased by 49% between 1974 and 2001. The 11 experts had a nuanced understanding of these changes and their causes. Their understanding was not only remarkably consistent with that of scientists, but it added considerable value to scientific understanding of the ultimate causes of land-cover change in the area. The experts listed combinations of several causal factors, operating at different spatial and temporal scales. The 40 randomly selected respondents also knew that forest and woodland cover had increased, but their understanding of the causes, and the role of fire in particular, was somewhat simplistic. They could identify only three causal factors and generally listed single factors rather than the combinations of factors listed by the experts. In some instances, their understanding even appeared to be seriously flawed. In contemporary Xhosa society, ecological knowledge is unevenly spread and held by individuals rather than by groups. Therefore, it is important to work with experts rather than randomly selected individuals in ecological studies that incorporate local knowledge. Expert local knowledge adds value to science by providing detailed insights into the ultimate causes of change, and by contributing a rare historical perspective. Scientists add value to local knowledge through their ability to study and predict obscure processes such as the impact of atmospheric change on vegetation. Scientists must, however, acknowledge that positivist studies that compare local knowledge to science are fraught with ethical and methodological challenges. Certain aspects of local knowledge, particularly in terms of fire, are sacred and do not have the same origins as Western science. Local knowledge and science can complement one another, but we advise against integrating them in a way that co-opts local knowledge for scientific purposes." en_US
dc.subject land tenure and use en_US
dc.subject indigenous institutions en_US
dc.subject social organization en_US
dc.subject landscape change en_US
dc.subject ecology en_US
dc.subject GIS en_US
dc.title Expert and Generalist Local Knowledge about Land-cover Change on South Africas Wild Coast: Can Local Ecological Knowledge Add Value to Science? en_US
dc.type Journal Article en_US
dc.type.published published en_US
dc.coverage.region Africa en_US
dc.coverage.country South Africa en_US
dc.subject.sector Social Organization en_US
dc.subject.sector Land Tenure & Use en_US
dc.subject.sector Information & Knowledge en_US
dc.identifier.citationjournal Ecology and Society en_US
dc.identifier.citationvolume 12 en_US
dc.identifier.citationnumber 1 en_US
dc.identifier.citationmonth January en_US

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
ES-2006-1977.pdf 172.7Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following document type(s)

Show simple item record