Image Database Export Citations


Let the Punishment fit the Crime: Self-Governed Communities in Southeastern Spain

Show full item record

Type: Conference Paper
Author: Espín-Sánchez, José-Antonio
Conference: Design and Dynamics of Institutions for Collective Action: A Tribute to Prof. Elinor Ostrom, Second Thematic Conference of the IASC
Location: Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands
Conf. Date: 29 November - 1 December
Date: 2012
URI: https://hdl.handle.net/10535/8647
Sector: Social Organization
Region: Europe
Subject(s): economic history
common pool resources
Abstract: "The standard crime and punishment literature predicts that it is optimal for the ruler to use the maximum punishment available in case a crime is committed. However, empirical studies show that punishments are, in general, smaller than the maximum punishment available. The usual explanation is that punishment is costly (i.e. maintaining the prisons, guards, etc). However, we do not observe the maximum punishment rule even in cases in which punishment is costless (i.e. trac nes). Moreover, punishments depend on the characteristics of the accused (i.e. teenagers receive lower punishments than adults for the same crime). However, the literature nds that the business cycle and the crime rate is uncorrelated. Hence, we need to explain why, imposing the maximum punishment is not optimal and why the punishments change with some observables and not others. I use a novel data set from a self-governed community of farmers in 19th-20th centuries Spain. In this data, the maximum punishment available is only rarely used, although punishment is costless. Also, punishments are aected by observables characteristics. In my data, there no correlation between the punishment and the business cycle. I propose a model that can explain the lack of maximum punishment, even when the punishment is costless. The model also gives an intuitive explanation for progressivity on the punishment. Finally, the model predicts that punishments (and crime rates) could be cyclical or counter-cyclical, depending on the parameters. I use the data to estimate and test the model."

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
Espin Sanchez.pdf 461.0Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following document type(s)

Show full item record