The Hybrid Governance of Urban Food Commons. Evidence from the Brussels-Capital Region
Loading...
Files
Date
2019
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
"Over the last three decades a revival of food commoning initiatives has occurred. Reacting
against shortcomings of conventional food chains, food commons pursue socio-political
transformation in established food and socio-political systems, towards more empowering
modes of local food systems’ governance.
Drawing from the conceptual apparatus and empirical findings of my PhD research, this
article aims to examine the critical governance tensions faced by food commoning
initiatives as they diversely develop. In particular, three types of governance tensions are
identified: organizational - i.e. tensions in governing the food network organizations as
they diversely develop, build alliances and networks; resource - i.e. tensions in accessing
and securing key resources (e.g. land, funding, material infrastructures, other key human
and natural resources); and institutional - i.e. tensions related to institutionalization
processes, and to the constraining or enabling role of key institutions with respect to the
agency of local food networks.
In the empirical part of this paper, these types of governance tensions and their
interrelations are briefly analysed in three case studies of urban food networks in the
Brussels-Capital Region (BCR): a Community Supported Agriculture Network called GASAP
(Groupes d'Achat Solidaires de l'Agriculture Paysanne) active in the BCR; the multi-agent
governance of the access to land for urban agriculture and its scaling out in the BCR; the
contested dynamics of institutionalizing alternative food systems through the
development and implementation of local food policies in the BCR.
This article argues that the Hybrid Governance analysis provides a more nuanced and
grounded characterization of the agency and socio-political dynamics of (food)
commoning initiatives as they diversely develop and pursue socio-political change. In
particular, the last part of this article discusses potential contributions of the Hybrid
Governance analysis to studies on collective action initiatives in general. These
contributions relate to a) a more complex characterization of the agency of collective action
initiatives; b) a more sound analysis of the connections between value systems and
cooperative practices; c) a better understanding of challenges and tensions experienced by
self-organizing initiatives in exercising greater socio-political transformation."
Description
Keywords
commons, governance, food supply, institutions