Exploring the Potential of Polycentric Governance to Cultivate Civic Virtue for Social-Ecological Sustainability, including by Re-enchanting Human-Nature Relationships
Loading...
Date
2024
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Much of humanity has become alienated from Nature as an enduring consequence of transformation at the IAD framework’s metaconstitutional level of analysis to a ‘disenchanted’, anthropocentric worldview rendering her of only instrumental value to humans. The resulting loss of affinity with Nature diminished the salience of calls for her protection, leading to a contemporary shortfall in the civic virtue ultimately required for successful collective action towards social-ecological sustainability.
This paper explores the potential of polycentric governance to ameliorate this shortfall, including by strengthening the contemporary salience of social-ecological sustainability by helping to ‘re-enchant’ human relationships with Nature. A review and synthesis of literature affirms such potential, particularly in respect of the community-based forms of polycentric governance informed by traditional Indigenous knowledge systems that Fikret Berkes identified as pivotal to sacred ecology as a re-enchanted tradition of ecological science. Such community-based forms of governance are informed by a non-anthropocentric, or community-of-beings, worldview wherein both humans and non-humans exercise agency in reciprocating each other’s contributions to social-ecological sustainability.
Community-based governance for this sustainability has advantages in protecting, and engaging people with, the opportunities for Nature experience that re-enchantment depends on. Efforts to realise these advantages faces formidable structural obstacles given the continuing hold of a disenchanted worldview. Overcoming these obstacles involves modest steps, each an experiment in practising reciprocity with Nature. Lessons gained across diverse communities filter upwards through the governance system to incrementally re-establish metaconstitutional conditions favouring human-Nature affinity.
Description
Keywords
polycentric governance, civic virtue, community-based governance, ecology, sustainability, social-ecological systems, collective action, social dilemmas